Working LINQ query does not work in unit test

I have a query very similar to this:

var result = context.EntityRole
   .Where(er => er.EntityType.EntityTypeId == entityTypeIdParameter
                && er.Entity.SomeItems.Any(item => item.ItemId == itemIdParameter))
   .ToList()
   .Distinct(customItemComparer)
   .OrderBy(er => er.Id)
   .ThenByDescending(er => er.IsApproved)
   .ToList();

The customItemComparer would be something similar to this:

public class CustomItemComparer : IEqualityComparer<EntityRole>
{
   public bool Equals(EntityRole x, EntityRole y)
   {
      if (ReferenceEquals(x, y)) return true;

      if (ReferenceEquals(x, null) || ReferenceEquals(y, null)) return false;

      return x.Property1 == y.Property1
             && x.Property2 == y.Property2
             && x.Property3 == y.Property3;
   }

   public int GetHashCode(EntityRole obj)
   {
      if (ReferenceEquals(obj, null)) return 0;

      var hasProperty1 = obj.Property1.GetHashCode();
      var hasProperty2 = obj.Property2.GetHashCode();
      var hasProperty3 = obj.Property3.GetHashCode();

      return hasProperyt1 ^ hasProperty2 ^ hasProperty3;
   }
}

The problem that I have is that when I run the application I get the expected results and apparently all the different scenarios work flawlessly, but when I try unit testing it the query always returns a single object even though the list contains more than one objects whose properties 1, 2, and 3 are different.

My unit test looks something like this, we are using MOQ, other properties removed for brevity:

var roles = new List<EntityRole>
{
   new EntityRole
   {
      Property1 = true,
      Property2 = 5,
      Property3 = "something"
   },
   new EntityRole
   {
      Property1 = true,
      Property2 = 9,
      Property3 = "something"
   },
   new EntityRole
   {
      Property1 = false,
      Property2 = 5,
      Property3 = "something"
   },
   new EntityRole
   {
      Property1 = true,
      Property2 = 5,
      Property3 = "something else"
   }
}

contextMock.Setup(c => c.EntityRole).Returns(roles.AsQueryable);

So like I said, even though there are no two objects identical in the list, the query always returns the first one.

Also if I put break points in the CustomItemComparer, the execution stops when running the application but it never stops when debugging the test.