NSubstitute conditions for throwing exception other than parameters

I'm using NSubstitute to mock a class that my method under test uses. This mocked class may throw a particular exception under certain conditions.

The method that I'm testing has some "retry" logic that it executes when it catches this exception. I'm trying to test this retry logic. So, I need a particular method of this mocked class to throw the exception sometimes, but not other times. Unfortunately, the method that throws this exception has no parameters, so I can't base the throw logic on parameters.

How can I make the mocked object's method throw the exception either:

A) ...the first N times it's called

or

B) ...based on the parameters some other method that's called before it

or

C) ...under any other condition other than the parameters passed in

To give you a clearer picture of what I'm trying to do, my code is something like:

IDataSender myDataSender = GetDataSender();
int ID = GetNextAvailableID();
myDataSender.ClearData();
myDataSender.Add(ID,"DataToSend");
bool sendSuccess = false;
while (!sendSuccess)
{
   try
   {
      myDataSender.SendData();
      sendSuccess = true;
   }
   catch (IDCollisionException)
   {
      ID++;
      MyDataSender.ClearData();
      myDataSender.Add(ID,"DataToSend");
   }
}

So, I need to test my retry logic, and I need to simulate that IDCollisionException. However, I can't have the SendData() throwing the exception every single time, or the retry loop will never succeed.

What can I do here?